Hello jlazaro317, thanks for reaching out. It sounds like you may have a slight incompatibility issue with the Maestro and Caseta dimmers that you don't have with your Toggler dimmer. This is because the Maestro and Caseta dimmers are more alike eachother than either are with the Toggler, since both the Maestro and Caseta are digital dimming controls that have different internals from the Toggler dimmer. The main difference is that the Maestro and Caseta do not completely cut power to the light fixture when they are in their "off-state" which would explain the faint glowing (a common symptom we refer to as ghosting). If you would like to use either the Maestro or Caseta dimmers, we would recommend swapping out the LED bulbs you are using with ones from our
LED Compatibility tool, linked here. Simply input your dimmer model and it will provide you with the full list of LED bulbs and fixtures that we have tested and confirmed good compatibility on; you can use the filters on the tool to narrow down the search to best match your current bulbs.